top of page

Building Common Ground: Why Canadian Passenger Rail Needs a National Framework

October 21, 2026

Andrew Kooiman, Director

Common success is an organizing principle of all well-functioning marketplaces. From pipelines to Silicon Valley, industries find ways to cooperate, in order to build and maintain a marketplace that supports all players and leads to successful outcomes.

Each role in an industry comes from a different perspective. Ours is a particularly complex industry where direct participants include public agencies, contractors, consultants, manufacturers, and educators. Adding stakeholders such as transit users, governments and utilities to the mix only increases the complexity.


From these different perspectives we must find common ground, where cooperation leads to benefits to all players. The challenges we face are many:

Cost – our jurisdiction has become a high-cost region, where even large budgets are over-run.

Schedule – Due to many factors, large projects are experiencing long delays to in-service.

Quality – First day experience for transit riders has been disappointing in several projects.


TRACCS believes at this point it is imperative that all players work together to find solutions wherever they lie. With a common understanding of better approaches to the procurement,

management and execution of large projects in our industry, each player would proceed to adapt their own approach.


Canada has some unique advantages to bring to this challenge. We have a strong, well educated work force. We have a strong political system, in general, with well defined roles. There is a national consensus that public transit is a key part of resolving the mobility challenges we face.


Despite the different roles, each player has an interest in creating a well-functioning marketplace. Changes in our marketplace to create better contractual frameworks, clear standards and a larger pool of qualified personnel will benefit all players.


Arash Barzegar, Market Sector Leader, Arcadis: “A strong marketplace has room for each player to contribute fully to common success. Cooperation in developing a better industry framework will be an effective way to improve project outcomes. Better project outcomes will benefit all players, and most importantly benefit the end user.”

Development of rail transit is a particularly complex endeavor. It demands a supply of a wide range of goods and services including heavy civil construction, specialized vehicles, rail infrastructure and systems. The final solution must work together seamlessly to deliver the agreed upon level of service for many years, with high reliability and reasonable maintenance cost.


“Fragmentation in rail project delivery is often felt at the interfaces between disciplines, contracts and project phases. It shows up when standards are unclear or inconsistent, when scope boundaries between suppliers do not align, and when contractual terms create uncertainty about responsibilities. In practice, these issues are experienced during design coordination, systems integration, testing and commissioning, where gaps or overlaps can lead to delay, rework and disputes. Better alignment across the industry would help create clearer expectations, smoother delivery and better outcomes for complex transit projects.” John Wood, Project Director, SYSTRA Canada


Examples of this fragmentation span from simple to the complex. As a simple example, many LRT and busway projects struggle with the implementation of a transit vehicle dedicated traffic signal at intersections. Sometimes a city will adopt an approach within their own borders, Toronto has done this. Where Ministry of Transportation Ontario is involved, they have their own standard. A recent project was faced with implementing two different approaches over a

simple 18 km line.


A more complex example is the implementation of Communication Based Train Control (CBTC) on a vehicle. The train control and vehicle are often supplied from different vendors. Coordination of this interface is complex and expensive. Some issues are relatively easy to navigate, such as space and power for the on-board equipment. Other issues may not even appear until the system is in operation. One example is software timeouts – where a message between the train control and vehicle must be confirmed; when this does not occur, subsequent actions can include an unneeded Emergency Stop, with significant impact on passengers and their groceries.


TRACCS is committed to developing a National Framework, for the benefit of all players in the industry. This framework will identify areas of cooperation, where change can bring better outcomes to rail projects.


Mark Salsberg, Chair, TRACCS: “TRACCS believes that development of a national framework will help industry players work together. It will allow a diverse group of industry players see the common ground where we can improve outcomes for all.”

Media Contact

Phillip Stainton
phillips@traccs.ca
Senior Advisor Marketing & Communications

bottom of page